Splashing in his Ocean Blue Eyes

Well, it happened! And it wasn't at all what I expected. I am officially no longer a virgin, I think.... I don't know what I expected exactly. But doing it...was, in fact, kind of like a close encounter of the third kind, or maybe, the fourth kind...if there is such a thing. I now know for a fact that there is! How do I know? Well, there I was in the pool getting it on with this cute guy. Now a random guy, my new friend Jeff who is a really cute, hot guy! (At least that's what I thought.) We were making out and I'm stroking his ass and it feels, well you know, but then, it felt different, it felt like not skin but like...I don't know what. I open my eyes and look down, and I swear to god, he had a fish's tail! Jeff had turned into a merman or something! Like that sea god Neptune, only he didn't have the big fork, but he did still have a big you know what! I mean it didn't fall off, it's just that instead of legs he was scaly and finny. It sounds kind of gross, but it was very smooth an